Lucky Cat Tattoos: MAJOR #fail. Twice.

Picture 13For those of you that have followed my blog for a while might remember in March when I went to get a tattoo on my wrist as a tribute to Harry.  I had “designed” it myself, although it was quite simple:  a big bold “lmL” with the words “Forever in my heart 8.11.76-1.22.09″ underneath it.  lmL was something special between Harry, Emily and myself, kind of an “inside family joke” that turned into something so much more.  I get questioned about it ALL the time (understandably so), so here is the story behind it:

Every morning, Harry and I would together walk Emily to the bus stop to send her off to school.  One of our neighbor’s kids used to wave to her Mom from the bus, but not a normal wave, she would use the hand symbol for I love you and wave it until her Mom did it back.  The first few times, I didn’t say anything and it was a few days later that Harry brought it up to me.  He said “do you see that girl waving her hand like that all the time?”  ”Yes, I do, it’s funny but very cute.” So we started to do it with Emily on the bus and she loved it.  It went from a goodbye on the bus to our goodbye all the time, no matter where we were.  Anytime we were leaving each other, we would use that hand symbol instead of waving.  Harry and Emily came up with these extensive handshakes that always included the hand symbol.  We even laughed about how our neighbors were probably making fun of us now as we had of them, but we didn’t care.  After a month or two, I realized that when you typed lmL it kind of looked like the hand symbol (the l was the pinky, the m was the middle fingers and the L was your pointy finger and thumb).  So from then on, any text message, e-mail or Facebook comment ended with lmL, in addition to our daily hand gestures.  Since Harry and I kept in contact via text messages all day, lmL was used quite often.  After I spoke at Harry’s funeral, I gave his urn the lmL hand symbol for one last time.  Emily and I still do it to this day.

So, now, that you know the meaning, let’s get back to the tattoo.  You can read the original post about the tattoo here, but I will give you the synopsis: I had attended a funeral that night for a co-worker’s Mom.  I had already drawn out the tattoo and had it in my bag and on my way home, thinking about how precious life really is, decided that I should get it done.  I said out loud: “Harry, if I should get this tattoo tonight, show me a sign!”.  No more than 3 minutes later, I came up on a tattoo shop, Lucky Cat Tattoos, in Miller Place, NY.  I said to myself, “if that isn’t a sign, I don’t know what is.”  When I walked in, there was one artist who was free at the time, Rob. While he was doing the tattoo, I noticed that he spelled Forever wrong.  He had made it Forover.  At first, he said I was wrong but then realized his mistake and made the o into an e.  At the time, it was not noticeable to anyone who didn’t know about it, but it was something that bothered me since I got it.

13796491After a few months, the o/e started to look obvious and the For in Forever and the 09 had faded out, almost to the point that it looked like they weren’t there.  I had shown this to MANY tattoo enthusiasts who balked and asked where I had gotten it done. They had never seen anything like it, especially in a tattoo that was only a few months old.  I waited another month to make sure it was completely healed before I complained.  I happened to be in the area of Lucky Cat Tattoos one day and thought I would stop in and see what they said.  I saw the store manager.  He said that the fading was “normal” on my wrist. Normal? I had never seen anything like this before. The tattoo artist that had done my tattoo was off that day.  I told the manager, “to be honest, I don’t want that artist touching my wrist again. He spelled Forever wrong!”. His response:  ”That is the only way we will fix it for free,” he said.  ”If you want a new artist, you will have to pay for another tattoo”.  Considering the guy had spelled something as simple as FOREVER wrong permanently on my body, I was really taken back by this.  However, I’m broke.  I could barely afford to get it done in the first place and couldn’t afford to get it re-done.  I was told when the artist was there and to come back.  Fast forward two months.  I had gotten really busy and I don’t live near the shop anymore.  I called ahead of time and got the artist on the phone.  He couldn’t remember me or the tattoo and denied the spelling mistake. He told me to come in and he would take a look.  As soon as I stopped in, he remembered me, the tattoo and the spelling mistake.  He (and the manager) told me they didn’t want to do it that night, he wanted a picture of it so that they could draw it out and figure out what letters needed to be retraced.  He said he would call me to come in at some point that week.  A week goes by, no call.  I call them and he says, “Oh, yeah, um, just come in whenever you want”.  So, back I go.  He tells me that they decided to just go over the entire tattoo again.  So basically, I could have had it done the week earlier, but had to wait a week for no reason.

I sit down in the chair and he begins.  All went well the the majority of the tattoo, until he gets to the lettering.  He tells me he is going to redraw the F with pen since you can’t really see it.  This makes me feel better but then he changes his mind. “I can see the F fine, I will just go over it again.” WELL…I guess he couldn’t see it that well because he COMPLETELY SCREWED IT UP!!!!  See the pic below of the tattoo as soon as it was finished:

app3701551255298851

The F is crooked, smaller and not lined up with the rest of the letters.  You can still see where the top of the F used to be.  I was sooooooo mad as soon as I saw it.  After I pointed it out, he realized his mistake… but it was too late.  The manager came over and suggested making all the letters bolder to fix the F.  I said, “you are not touching my skin again”.  He told me to come back in a few weeks and they would try to figure out how to fix it AGAIN.  Basically, he screwed up the ONE THING that I went to get fixed.  I also noticed later that the 1.22 looks like 7.22 now and there is no dot over the i in the word “in” as there was before.I have never, in my life, met a group of more incompetent people.  People have said in the past few days, “it’s not THAT bad”. It’s tattooed on my body, for life.  When you get tattoos, you don’t want them to be BAD at all, only perfect will do, and this is far from it.  If this was just a tattoo that had no meaning, it would be one thing, but this is a tribute to the love of my life and it has turned into a disaster. I’m hoping that the F fades AGAIN and I will go to a tattoo artist that has actual talent to get it fixed, not some 21 year old moron who doesn’t know what he is doing.  (BTW, he has an apprentice. I don’t think he should be one to teach anyone anything).

So, a word of advice: Check out your tattoo parlor before you go.  Don’t just take the artist that is available at the time.  There is probably a reason why every other artist was busy and he wasn’t.





  • http://revelationszero.com Revelations Zero

    At least that tattoo’s somewhere easily covered up until it does fade and you get it fixed. Not somewhere like your upper arm. Or did you ever hear about that girl who thought it would be a good idea to get a bunch of stars tattooed on her face.

    I hope it all works out for you. I’ve been thinking about getting one myself, so thanks for the advice. I’m sure there’s probably some legal action you can take for them screwing up….I dunno.

  • Jon

    I just kind of stumbled upon this. And I know I’m a little late in responding to this. I had my tattoo done by Rob as well. It wasn’t anything ridiculous or extravagant. It was a simple tattoo of my grandfather’s signature “Johnny”. My grandfather past away close to nine years ago and the only signatures I could find from my grandfather was his old social security card and a letter to my mother he had written. Because the soc. security card only had my grandfathers full name, “John”, Rob was able and very helpful in replicating his handwriting by analyzing the letter my grandfather had written. I recreated the other “n” and “y” and made it a perfect match. He put the needle to my arm and gave me a great tattoo that i could remember my grandpa with. I understand that you are very upset with how your tattoo came out, but in my honest opinion, I think it was just an unfortunate case that spiraled out of control. I don’t mean to say that you shouldn’t be angry. But I feel that if this was just a very horrible one-time experience I hope others do not get the wrong impression of Lucky Cat. I have only heard good things about them and definitely enjoyed my experience.

  • missbeckala

    Thanks for responding Jon, but I am still mad about the entire situation. And not just about the tattoo, but how they responded to the situation. When I tried to call and speak to a manager, calls were never returned. I also left comments on their YouTube page to try to get in contact with someone and they were deleted, without a response. That is just bad customer service, especially considering the mistakes he made twice on something I have to live with every day. You would think they would give a partial refund or something, but no, they won’t even speak to me. I think it should be the other way around. I have gotten tattoos at Tattoo Lou’s and one by Cliff himself of Cliff’s Tattoos and all 3 times, it was a much better experience. I posted this to warn people about that place. Just because you had a great experience, that shouldn’t discount my horrible one.

  • http://www.tribal-art.ch/ arm tattoo

    I think Kate v D is the greatest tattoo artist in the world, I really love her tattoos.

  • http://www.tribal-art.ch/ tattoo black

    I really love the tattoo artists on Miami ink and La ink, it is just amazing what they can draw and then tattoo.

  • http://www.become-a-veterinary-technician.com/ veterinary technician

    nice post. thanks.

  • Dave

    I have read both of your blogs regarding your experience with this tattoo shop, first off I want to say I’m a avid tattoo collector and have a lot of work done by a lot of artists all over country. You neglected to tell the tattoo artist that you were on a blood thinner?!?! A blood thinner is a anti-clotting medication that hinders healing of a tattoo the thinner the blood the harder healing and fading of a tattoo. Second, you did go to one of the apprentices instead of waiting for a artist who has experience under his belt, not to be disrespectful or rude, but I think you were either in a rush to get this tattoo or didn’t care who did the tattoo. so I think that your blog bashing this place of business is misplaced.

  • Becky

    Dear Dave,
    I wasn’t told he was “an apprentice” when I came in. Do you think if I was, I would have gone to him? It’s too bad the owner or manager never contacted me before I posted this blog (and they were given plenty of chances when I called and came in to complain) – maybe this post wouldn’t come up 4th on Google when you search their name. That’s what they get for HORRIBLE customer service!

  • Tattootony

    i guess if u had a dog, “Forover” would be sufficient..lol…robs a great guy..he tattooed me as well!!! good people there
    tony laf Owner/artist Devils Den Tattoo Copiague
    http://www.devilsdentattoo.com

  • Treeguy1111

    I just stumbled across this blog while looking at tattoo shops in my area, I have a question for Becky. Prior to sitting down with someone to get a tattoo don’t you think it would be a good idea to look at some of their past work? With that being said, I know all of the artists in this shop very well, and not only are you so off with your criticizing remarks but you have managed to mock some of the best tattoo artists on the island. Secondly, if you had put any thought into where you were putting this tattoo you would have realized that the rist is one of the toughest places to get a tattoo and have it stay perfect. It is a jointed area and it constantly is moving, how do you expect the human body to heal when the area moves? Would a broken are mend if you constantly moved it? I think not…. In closing, it would probably be a good idea for you to put a little more thought into your tattoos and less thought into who you can blame for your own mistakes.

Visit My Other Site
Like Me!
Basically Becky on LinkedIn



The Website Grade for basicallybecky.com!
Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes